Last week, the Nifty 50 Index touched a significant milestone, crossing 25,000 points. This is noteworthy not just for the number itself but for the pace at which it was achieved—just 221 trading sessions, or roughly eleven months. While this milestone is cause for celebration for many investors, whose portfolios are also reaching all-time highs, we believe it’s a prudent time to reassess the risks in equities.
Valuation Concerns:
Price to Earnings Ratio: The trailing P/E ratio of the BSE500 currently stands at 31x, a level comparable to the pre-COVID era and about 10% higher than the 2007 peak. While these elevated valuations have persisted for some time, the current macroeconomic and earnings backdrop differs significantly from previous periods. In 2017 and post-COVID, low interest rates were a crucial support for these valuations. Today, however, the primary driver is earnings.
Price to Book Ratio: On a P/B basis, the BSE500 is trading at 4.5x, which is 20% higher than pre-COVID levels but below the 2007 Global Financial Crisis peak of 6.5x. The difference lies in the Return on Equity (RoE) profile—while the BSE500 RoE was 25% at the 2007 peak, it was just 10% in 2018 and is around 15% today.
Market Cap to GDP Ratio: The market cap to GDP ratio has once again reached the previous peak of 150% from 2007. This metric effectively captures both primary and secondary market sentiments. However, the economic backdrop has changed—while nominal GDP was growing in the mid-to-high teens in 2007, it is now struggling to reach double digits. This disparity suggests that current market valuations may be out of sync with the real economy.
Why Do Valuations Matter?
When it comes to investing, the initial valuation at which you enter a position is crucial in determining your medium-term returns. While the impact of valuations on short-term performance can be less predictable, their influence over the medium term is undeniable and often decisive.
In light of these rich valuations across multiple metrics, we advise exercising caution in the current market environment. While there may still be opportunities, the potential risks should not be overlooked.
Other indicators which may prove that the market is in overvalued zone:
1. Record number of IPOs
2. NFOs raising record money in sectoral funds
3. Promotor selling in secondary market
4. Increase in speculative ideas
However, these parameters overlook the concerns surrounding valuations:
Liquidity: With record monthly inflows from SIPs, EPF, NPS, and insurance funds, the market is currently flush with liquidity. The fundamental driver of these flows is income growth, which, if sustained, will likely have positive spillovers across various asset classes.
Strong Balance Sheets: Historically, Indian and emerging market earnings have moved in tandem. However, since the post-COVID recovery, India Inc.’s earnings have significantly outperformed those of other emerging markets. Additionally, from a corporate balance sheet perspective, Indian companies are now much more deleveraged.
CAPEX Cycle Sustainability: The government has been focused on building infrastructure and has invested record amounts over the medium term. For continued economic growth, it’s essential that this CAPEX cycle remains robust.
Predicting the exact inflection points in a market with strong momentum is very challenging. However, we believe that at this stage, the margin of safety is limited.
What Should You Do as an Investor?
The fundamental drivers of India’s multi-decade consumption and infrastructure growth, are still firmly in place. While predicting market direction is impossible, careful planning is essential. If your financial goal is approaching in 2024, it might be wise to consider moving funds out of equities and into safer investment options.
For fresh lump-sum investments, a flexible approach that allows you to diversify across sectors/asset classes could be prudent—consider options like Multi-Asset or Flexicap funds.
For other existing investors, we recommend to stay invested as India’s long-term growth story remains intact.
For SIPs, it’s advisable to continue them, keeping in mind your financial goals and risk tolerance.
We remain vigilant and committed to providing insights that help you navigate these complex market conditions. Please do not hesitate to reach out if you have any questions or would like to discuss this further.